A raw food diet for dogs is built on uncooked meat, offal and often bone, sold frozen, chilled or freeze-dried, or mixed at home. The BARF diet for dogs (usually expanded as “biologically appropriate raw food” or “bones and raw food”) is the best-known version. Owners choose it for perceived health benefits and out of distrust of industrially processed food.
A 2019 review by the UK Animal and Plant Health Agency sets out where the evidence stands.[1] Formal evidence supports two of the claims made for raw feeding: a different gut microbiome and, judged subjectively, better stool quality. For most other claimed benefits there is “neither robust evidence nor identified plausible mechanisms”. The documented risks are malnutrition, from inexpert formulation and testing, and infection of pets and the people they live with.[1]
So the question “is raw food good for dogs?” has two separate parts: is the product microbiologically safe, and is it nutritionally complete? This article takes them in turn, then sets out what a safer raw product needs.
Raw dog food safety starts with the ingredient. Meat and offal can carry bacteria from the animal and the slaughter line, and a raw recipe has no step that removes them. Product surveys in the US and Europe show how often this reaches the finished food.
| Study | Samples | What was found |
|---|---|---|
| US FDA Vet-LIRN and FERN laboratories, 2010–2012[2][3] | 196 raw dog and cat foods (plus 480 dry and semi-moist foods) | Raw: 15 positive for Salmonella, 32 for Listeria monocytogenes. Dry and semi-moist: 2 positives in 480 samples |
| Netherlands, 2018[4] | 35 frozen raw meat-based diets, 8 brands | E. coli O157:H7 in 23%, ESBL-producing E. coli 80%, L. monocytogenes 54%, Salmonella 20%; parasites (Sarcocystis, Toxoplasma gondii) in 6–11% |
| Minneapolis/St Paul, US, 2012[5] | 60 raw diets, 11 brands | 4 (7%) positive for Salmonella; none of the stores gave a foodborne illness warning |
The studies used different methods, years and markets, so the percentages should not be pooled or compared directly. The pattern is consistent, though: the APHA review notes that surveys in Europe and North America “have consistently found Salmonella” in a proportion of samples, typically fresh-frozen commercial diets, and that raw pet food commonly exceeds hygiene thresholds for Enterobacteriaceae.[1]
Salmonella and L. monocytogenes are the pathogens regulators name first.[3][11] Shiga toxin-producing E. coli (STEC) such as O157:H7 is rarer but can cause severe illness in people.[8] A newer concern is antimicrobial resistance: the bacteria in raw pet food often carry resistance to critically important antibiotics such as extended-spectrum cephalosporins, and raw-fed pets have a higher risk of shedding them.[1] Parasites are a further hazard, particularly if meat is fed without freezing.[4]
Cooked and dry foods are not risk-free. A 2024 review counted more than 117 US pet food recalls for Salmonella since 1999 across product types, including kibble and treats, 11 of them linked to human outbreaks.[6] Our report on a US dog treat recall for Salmonella is one example. The difference is that dry food goes through a cooking step, while a raw product depends entirely on the controls described below.
Dogs. A 2025 report from Bulgaria describes a Salmonella Agona outbreak in a Rottweiler breeding kennel linked to raw meat-based food of unlicensed origin.[7] Dogs vomited and had diarrhoea, post-partum bitches were worst affected, and the bacterium was found in faeces, the food and the kennel environment. All dogs recovered once raw feeding stopped and the kennel was treated and disinfected; all human contacts tested negative.[7]
Carriage in healthy household dogs. In a UK study of faecal samples from 114 raw-fed and 76 non-raw-fed dogs, Salmonella was found only in raw-fed dogs (eight dogs). Antimicrobial-resistant E. coli was found in 54% of raw-fed dogs against 17% of non-raw-fed dogs.[9] The authors advise households with very young, elderly or immunocompromised members to be aware of the risk.[9]
People. In August 2017, Public Health England identified a cluster of four people infected with related strains of STEC O157:H7; one died after developing haemolytic uraemic syndrome. Three of the four had been exposed to dogs fed raw tripe, and STEC was isolated from one sample of raw tripe, although it was not the outbreak strain.[8] The authors describe raw pet food as an emerging potential source of human STEC infection.[8]
Avian influenza. The FDA determined on 17 January 2025 (updated 30 September 2025) that US cat and dog food manufacturers covered by its Preventive Controls for Animal Food rule, and using uncooked or unpasteurised poultry or cattle materials, must reanalyse their food safety plans to include H5N1 as a known or reasonably foreseeable hazard.[10]
| Body | Position |
|---|---|
| CDC (US) | Does not recommend feeding raw pet food or treats to dogs and cats; advises talking to a veterinarian first.[11] |
| FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine | Concerned about the public health risk of raw pet food, based on its own testing.[3] |
| AVMA | Discourages feeding raw or undercooked animal-source protein to dogs and cats because of the risk to human and animal health; supports diets processed to reduce pathogens.[12] |
| European Union | Raw petfood is regulated under the animal by-products rules. Samples taken during production or storage must show Salmonella absent in 25 g (n = 5, c = 0), and production must meet an Enterobacteriaceae process hygiene criterion.[13] |
| India | The Bureau of Indian Standards specification for dog and cat food is IS 11968:2019 (first revision).[14] Which pet food rules are mandatory for an Indian brand is covered in our guide to pet food regulations in India; see also our note on nutritional standards under IS 11968:2019. |
None of these bodies bans raw feeding. Their shared advice is that a raw diet should not be fed by default, that anyone who does feed it should follow strict hygiene, and that vulnerable people and pets need most protection. CDC lists children under 5, adults aged 65 and over, pregnant women and people with weakened immune systems, and among pets, puppies and animals with weakened immune systems or other health conditions.[11]
A “complete and balanced” food supplies every essential nutrient in the right amounts for a stated life stage. Meat, offal and bone alone are high in some nutrients and low in others, so the balance depends on the recipe.
The clearest data come from home-made rations. A German study calculated the composition of 95 bone and raw food rations fed to adult dogs.[15] Sixty per cent had one or more imbalances: 10% supplied less than a quarter of the recommended allowance for calcium (with a calcium-to-phosphorus ratio below 0.6:1 and low vitamin D), about half supplied less iodine than the minimum requirement, many were low in zinc and copper, and a quarter supplied 70% or less of the recommended vitamin A. Most of the remaining 40% had minor problems, such as excess calcium from bone.[15]
Commercial products are not automatically better. In the Minneapolis survey, none of the 60 raw diets had been through a feeding trial, nutritional adequacy was substantiated by formulation only, and three brands did not meet FDA label requirements.[5]
In the US, a dog food can claim to be complete and balanced in one of two ways: by meeting an AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profile, or by passing a feeding trial using AAFCO procedures.[16] European makers use the FEDIAF Nutritional Guidelines (2025 edition), which build on the National Research Council’s Nutrient Requirements of Dogs and Cats (2006).[17][18] For a raw recipe, that means formulating to a published profile and then confirming the finished batch by laboratory analysis, because raw ingredients vary from lot to lot.
Cooking and extrusion can reduce some heat-sensitive nutrients, which is the core of the raw-feeding argument; our guide to nutrient losses in pet food processing shows how formulators allow for them. Kibble is cooked and usually formulated to a profile, so it is more consistent from bag to bag; raw depends on the recipe, the ingredient lot and the person making it. Neither format is simply better. The honest comparison is between specific products and the evidence behind each.
No single control makes raw dog food safe. Safety comes from layers, each managing a different risk.
Table 1. Controls for a raw dog food and what each manages
| Control | What it manages | Who owns it |
|---|---|---|
| Approved suppliers and incoming checks | Pathogens on raw meat; for poultry and cattle materials in the US, H5N1 is now a hazard to address[10] | Brand and supplier |
| Complete and balanced recipe | Nutritional imbalance[15][16] | Formulator |
| Validated pathogen-reduction step | Surviving bacteria. High pressure processing (HPP) keeps the product raw; a heat step makes it a lightly cooked product[19][20] | Manufacturer |
| Sealed pack and cold chain | Growth during storage. Freezing, freeze-drying and dehydrating reduce germs but do not kill all of them[11] | Brand and distributor |
| Owner handling instructions | Spread to people at home[3][11] | Brand and owner |
HPP is the usual non-thermal option for raw pet food, and two peer-reviewed studies show both its value and its limits. In a US study of eight commercial raw diets inoculated with pathogens, 586 MPa for at least 2 minutes gave a 5-log reduction of Salmonella in one formulation type, held during frozen storage, and STEC reached 5 logs from day 6 of frozen storage; L. monocytogenes was more resistant and did not reach a 5-log reduction, and results varied with formulation and species of meat.[19] A Spanish study found Salmonella reductions of 1 to 9 logs depending on pressure, time and added lactic acid, with frozen storage after HPP giving further inactivation.[20] Our review of HPP versus thermal pasteurisation covers the method in more detail.
The practical lesson is that an HPP setting proven on one recipe does not transfer automatically to another with different meat, organ, bone or acid content. Each product needs its own validation.[19][20]
CDC and FDA advise washing hands with soap and water before and after handling raw pet food, cleaning bowls, utensils and surfaces, thawing frozen raw food in the refrigerator, storing it sealed and away from other food, and throwing away leftovers left at room temperature.[3][11] Owners considering raw food for a puppy, an older dog or a dog with a health condition, or living with a vulnerable person, should discuss it with their veterinarian first.[11]
Safe raw products are designed, not assembled, and raw dog food safety is proven on batches, not assumed. A brand launching a raw or BARF-style product needs:
FRL’s raw and fresh pet diet development service covers ingredient profiling, custom formulation, pilot-scale trials with cold-chain checks, nutrient analysis and microbial validation, including HPP where required. We run or arrange testing through accredited partner laboratories, and palatability or acceptance trials with animals are run or arranged through partner facilities. For a lightly cooked alternative, see fresh and cooked pet food development; for the full range of formats, see pet food formulation and R&D services. To see how a pet product moves from bench to pilot batch, read our dog treat pilot batch worked example.
Raw diets carry documented risks. US and European surveys regularly find Salmonella and Listeria in raw pet food, and home-made raw rations are often nutritionally unbalanced. CDC does not recommend raw feeding and AVMA discourages it. If you do feed raw, choose a complete and balanced product with a validated pathogen-reduction step and talk to your veterinarian.[1][11][12]
The two main risks are bacterial contamination and nutritional imbalance. Raw meat can carry Salmonella, Listeria monocytogenes, Shiga toxin-producing E. coli and antibiotic-resistant bacteria, which can sicken dogs and spread to people. Home-made raw recipes frequently lack calcium, iodine, zinc, copper or vitamin A, and some contain too much calcium from bone.[1][4][15]
There is no robust evidence that raw food is better overall. Studies support a different gut microbiome and, subjectively, better stools in raw-fed dogs, but not most other claimed benefits. Kibble is cooked and usually formulated to a nutrient profile, while raw quality depends on the recipe and controls. Judge the specific product rather than the category.[1]
Yes. Bacteria from raw pet food can spread to hands, bowls and kitchen surfaces, and raw-fed dogs can carry Salmonella without looking ill. A 2017 UK cluster of E. coli O157 infections, including one death, was linked to dogs fed raw tripe. Children under five, older adults, pregnant women and immunocompromised people are most at risk.[8][9][11]
No. CDC says freezing, freeze-drying and dehydrating reduce germs in raw pet food but do not kill all of them. Freezing mainly stops bacteria from growing during storage. A validated step such as high pressure processing is needed to reduce pathogens, and frozen product should be thawed in the refrigerator and handled with strict hygiene.[11][19][20]
Brands layer several controls: approved suppliers and incoming checks, a complete and balanced recipe confirmed by analysis, a pathogen-reduction step such as high pressure processing validated on that recipe, an unbroken cold chain, and clear handling instructions on the pack. Studies show HPP results vary with formulation, and Listeria is harder to reduce than Salmonella.[19][20]