Every pet food process trades something. Heat makes food safe, gelatinises starch and gives shelf life; it also destroys some vitamins, binds part of the lysine and can change how well other nutrients are absorbed. Four variables decide how much is lost: temperature, time, moisture and oxygen. A short, cool process keeps more than one that must sterilise, and fats and fat-soluble vitamins keep oxidising in the pack after the food is made.[2]
Nutrient profiles are written for the food as eaten, not the recipe. AAFCO states that its dog and cat food nutrient profiles give the concentrations expected when the food is consumed, and that manufacturers must make allowances before processing for losses during processing and storage.[1] FEDIAF recommends that every complete pet food is validated by chemical analysis of the finished product, and re-analysed after any major change in formulation or processing.[3] Nutrient losses in pet food processing are therefore a design input for pet food product development, not a surprise found at the end.
This guide compares raw, cooked or canned, and extruded foods, then uses taurine to show how a loss becomes a formulation decision. For the rules that apply to selling pet food in India, start with our guide to pet food regulations in India.
Raw diets carry no heat load, so heat-sensitive vitamins are not lost in a cooker or extruder. They are not loss-free: fats oxidise and quality changes with time and temperature in the cold chain. Some raw ingredients also bring their own risk. Raw freshwater fish and clams contain thiaminases, enzymes that destroy dietary thiamine; cooking destroys them, and the heat of canning is enough to do so.[4]
The bigger issue is safety. Raw diets have no kill step. In published studies reviewed in 2024, the prevalence of Salmonella in raw pet foods ranged from 0 to 80%, and the reviewers note a lack of validated heat and chemical interventions for raw pet foods; non-thermal steps such as high pressure processing (HPP) and freeze-drying may be considered.[5] Our companion review, is a raw food diet for dogs safe?, sets out the pathogen and nutrition evidence in full.
Processing is not simply bad for nutrition either. A 2025 systematic review of fresh pet food claims found that the effect of processing on digestibility and nutrient content depended on the ingredient and the method, with both beneficial and detrimental outcomes, rather than on processing intensity alone.[6] In the raw vs cooked vs extruded comparison, raw keeps the most heat-sensitive nutrients and carries the most pathogen risk. See our raw and fresh diet development and freeze-dried pet food development pages, and our article on freeze-dried pet food technology.
Gently cooked fresh foods are heated enough to make them safe for a chilled shelf life. Canned and retort-pouch foods are sterilised in the sealed pack, and the heat must reach the slowest-heating point of every can or pouch, so they carry the heaviest heat load in the wet category.
Thiamine (vitamin B1) is the vitamin most often lost. AAFCO’s nutrient profiles warn that processing may destroy up to 90% of the thiamine in a diet and tell formulators to make allowances so that the minimum is still met after processing.[1] Overheating during drying or canning has caused thiamine destruction, although deficiency is rare in properly made complete and balanced foods.[4]
Heat also drives the Maillard reaction between reducing sugars and the lysine in protein, which leaves part of the lysine unavailable even though a standard amino acid analysis still counts it.[7] In cats, heat processing has a further, less obvious effect on taurine, covered below: canned cat food needs about twice the taurine of dry food.[3] Wet formats are covered on our wet pet food development and fresh and cooked pet food pages; for sterilised formats see our retort wet pet food development page and our guide to retort food formulation.
Most dry pet food (kibble) is made by extrusion: a moist dough is cooked under heat, pressure and shear for a short time, forced through a die, then dried, cooled and coated with fat and palatants. The same conditions that gelatinise starch and kill bacteria also stress vitamins and amino acids, which is why pet food extrusion nutrient loss is a balance rather than a fixed figure.
A review of vitamin stability in extrusion found that barrel temperature, screw speed, ingredient moisture, die diameter and throughput all affect retention. Vitamins A and E, and vitamin C, thiamine and folic acid, are the most sensitive; riboflavin, vitamin B6, B12, niacin, pantothenate and biotin are stable. Vitamins A, C, D and E are also sensitive to oxidation, so they keep falling during storage of the extruded food.[2]
In 67 commercial dog and cat foods, the ratio of reactive (still available) lysine to total lysine averaged 0.87 in extruded dog foods, 0.97 in canned and 0.85 in pelleted dog foods, with a lowest value of 0.77 in an extruded food for growing dogs. In cat foods the averages were 0.91 (extruded) and 0.90 (canned), with a lowest value of 0.67. The authors concluded that ingredients, rather than processing type, may be the key factor, and that some foods for growing dogs could be at risk of not meeting the minimum lysine requirement.[8] A separate study of 20 cat foods found that conventional digestible total lysine overestimated available lysine by 38 to 143%.[9] Ask for reactive lysine, not just total lysine, when lysine is close to the minimum.
Fats are usually coated onto the kibble after the extruder, together with palatants and, in some formulas, heat-sensitive ingredients. Coating protects those ingredients from extruder heat, but it is also the step most suspected of recontaminating kibble with pathogens after the kill step, so it needs its own hygiene controls.[5] Once made, oxidation continues in the bag; our guide to packaging for dry pet food covers the oxygen and moisture barrier that slows it. For a worked look at extruded kibble, see reverse engineering an extruded dog food, and for development work our kibble development page.
Table 1. Raw vs cooked vs extruded pet food: main nutrient effects and responses
| Process | Nutrients most exposed | Typical formulation response |
|---|---|---|
| Raw (with or without HPP or freeze-drying) | Little heat loss; fats oxidise in storage; thiamine at risk from thiaminase in raw fish[4] | Pathogen control and cold chain[5]; antioxidants; avoid raw thiaminase sources |
| Cooked, canned or retort | Thiamine (up to 90% loss possible)[1]; lysine via Maillard reaction[7]; taurine status in cats[3] | Thiamine allowance; higher taurine minimum for canned cat food[1][3]; process schedule designed with the recipe |
| Extruded (kibble) | Vitamins A, E, C, thiamine, folic acid[2]; reactive lysine[8]; oxidation of vitamins A, C, D, E in storage[2] | Vitamin overage; post-extruder coating; reactive lysine check; barrier packaging and end-of-shelf-life analysis |
Taurine is a sulphur-containing amino sulfonic acid that dogs and cats use to conjugate bile acids. Cats cannot make enough of it, so it is an essential nutrient for them; healthy dogs make enough from the sulphur amino acids methionine and cysteine.[3] In 1987, low plasma taurine was linked to dilated cardiomyopathy in 21 cats fed commercial cat foods, and taurine supplementation was associated with normalised heart function.[10] That finding is why every complete cat food now carries a taurine minimum.
Taurine is not mainly lost on the line. The problem is what heat-processed food does in the gut. Cats fed a heat-processed commercial diet exhaled 9.4% of an oral dose of labelled taurine as carbon dioxide, against 0.09% for the same diet frozen-preserved, showing extensive breakdown by gut bacteria.[11] Cats fed Maillard reaction products had twice the faecal taurine excretion of controls and depleted plasma taurine, which antibiotics reversed.[12] Cooking method matters too: ingredients cooked surrounded by water (boiling, basting) lost more taurine than baked or fried ones.[13]
The nutrient profiles build this in. AAFCO’s cat food profiles set taurine at 0.10% of dry matter for extruded food and 0.20% for canned food, at or above the 2006 NRC recommended allowance.[1][14] FEDIAF sets 0.10 g/100 g dry matter for dry and 0.20 g/100 g for canned adult cat food (at 100 kcal/kg0.67 energy intake), noting that heat-processed wet food needs about 2 to 2.5 times the taurine of dry extruded food.[3]
Neither the AAFCO dog profile nor the FEDIAF dog tables set a taurine minimum.[1][3] FEDIAF notes that low taurine status can still occur in dogs fed very low-protein diets, foods low in available sulphur amino acids, or some lamb and rice foods, that some breeds such as Newfoundlands are more sensitive, and that dog foods should maintain whole-blood taurine above 200 µmol/L (plasma above 40 µmol/L).[3] In 24 golden retrievers with taurine deficiency and dilated cardiomyopathy, 23 were fed grain-free or legume-rich diets, and 23 improved after a diet change and taurine supplementation.[15] The US FDA, which investigated reports of diet-associated canine cardiomyopathy, said in its last update (December 2022) that case reports alone do not establish a causal link.[16] Adding taurine to dog food is a formulation choice, not a legal minimum, but it is a common one for diets low in animal protein or sulphur amino acids.
Suppose a dry cat food targets the 1,000 mg/kg dry matter minimum (0.10%) and trials show that 80% of the added taurine is recovered in the finished food. The amount to add is the target divided by retention: 1,000 ÷ 0.80 = 1,250 mg/kg, a 25% overage. The retention figures in Table 2 and Figure 1 are assumptions chosen to show the calculation, not measured values. For taurine, the standards’ higher minimum for canned food already covers the reduced bioavailability; the overage covers what your analysis shows is lost between the mixer and the end of shelf life.
Table 2. Taurine to add for a 1,000 mg/kg dry matter target at assumed retentions (calculated)
| Retention through processing and storage | Taurine to add | Overage |
|---|---|---|
| 100% | 1,000 mg/kg | 0% |
| 90% | 1,111 mg/kg | 11.1% |
| 80% | 1,250 mg/kg | 25.0% |
| 70% | 1,429 mg/kg | 42.9% |
Never set an overage from a table like this. Run processing trials on the real recipe, analyse taurine, thiamine and the other at-risk nutrients before and after processing, and set the overage from results at the end of shelf life, not at the extruder die. The same logic is used for vitamins in supplements, as our guide to vitamin D overage shows.
Replacing losses follows the same five steps whatever the process:
Overages have limits. Some nutrients have maximum levels, and over-fortifying a stable vitamin to cover an unstable one wastes money, so the overage should be nutrient-specific. Our articles on real-time and accelerated shelf-life testing and scaling a recipe from kitchen to pilot plant cover the study design. Our worked example of a dog treat pilot batch shows where these trials sit in a start-up’s first production run.
Start from the product promise, then choose the process, then the overage and test plan:
The raw vs cooked vs extruded decision sets which nutrients need an overage, which can be added after processing and which can be left alone. Where the choice is close, run two routes on the same recipe in pilot trials and decide on measured retention, cost and safety. Pet food sold in India is also subject to labelling and import rules; check them in our pet food regulations in India guide before you finalise the label claim.
This is the science hub of FRL’s pet food series. Each companion piece takes one decision further:
Nutrient losses in pet food processing are predictable, measurable and manageable. Raw diets keep heat-sensitive nutrients but carry the most pathogen risk; canned and retort foods lose thiamine and, in cats, reduce taurine status; extruded foods lose sensitive vitamins and some available lysine and keep losing vitamins in storage. Set the target from AAFCO or FEDIAF, measure retention in trials, add a nutrient-specific overage and confirm it at the end of shelf life.
Food Research Lab works from Chennai, India, with pet food brands and manufacturers. Our pet food formulation and R&D services cover formulation of complete, functional and therapeutic diets and process development across extrusion, baking, freeze-drying, HPP and retort sterilisation, with pilot trials and scale-up. For wet formats we run pilot trials at our pilot retort unit in Chennai. We design the processing trials and overage calculations described here, and run or arrange nutrient analysis and stability testing through accredited partner laboratories; palatability and acceptance trials with animals are run or arranged through partner facilities.
See also our kibble, wet pet food, freeze-dried and raw and fresh diet development pages, and regulatory and scientific research for label claims. You can also contact us with your recipe, process and target market.
Cooking reduces some nutrients and improves others. Heat destroys part of the thiamine and other sensitive vitamins and can make some lysine unavailable through the Maillard reaction, but it also kills pathogens and makes starch and protein easier to digest. The net effect depends on the ingredient, the process and how the recipe allows for losses.
Extrusion cooks kibble with heat, moisture, pressure and shear for a short time. Vitamins A, E, C, thiamine and folic acid are the most sensitive, while several B vitamins are stable. Some lysine becomes unavailable through the Maillard reaction. Manufacturers add vitamin overages, coat sensitive ingredients after the extruder and confirm levels at the end of shelf life.
Cats cannot make enough taurine, so complete cat foods must meet a taurine minimum; a deficiency causes heart and eye disease. Healthy dogs make taurine from methionine and cysteine, and AAFCO and FEDIAF set no dog minimum, but some formulators add it to diets low in animal protein or sulphur amino acids, or for sensitive breeds.
Heat-processed canned food changes the cat’s gut bacteria so that more taurine is broken down and lost in the faeces instead of being recycled. To compensate, AAFCO sets 0.20% taurine on a dry matter basis for canned cat food against 0.10% for extruded food, and FEDIAF says wet food needs about 2 to 2.5 times more.
Raw food keeps more heat-sensitive vitamins, but a well-formulated extruded or canned food is also complete and balanced because losses are replaced with overages. Raw food has no kill step, and studies have found Salmonella in up to 80% of samples in some surveys. Delivered nutrition depends on formulation and testing more than on the process.
An overage is the extra amount of a nutrient added before processing so that the finished food still meets its target at the end of shelf life. It equals the target divided by the measured retention, minus one. For example, if 80% of added taurine is retained, adding 1,250 mg/kg delivers a 1,000 mg/kg target.