Low sugar drink reformulation is reworking a beverage recipe to cut sugar below a regulatory threshold—such as the UK levy’s lower band—while keeping the sweetness, mouthfeel and flavour shoppers expect; however, meeting the sugar number alone does not guarantee consumer acceptance. For a drink targeting the 4.5g/100ml 2028 threshold, the technical challenge is to reduce enough sugar to create regulatory headroom while preserving sweetness dynamics, mouthfeel, flavour balance and repeat-use acceptance.
Dr. Shreya Iyer, PhD (Food Science) — Director of New Product Development, Food Research Lab
Specialization: Food formulation, beverage development, and culinary innovation
Low sugar drink reformulation is reworking a beverage recipe to cut sugar below a regulatory threshold—such as the UK levy’s lower band—while keeping the sweetness, mouthfeel and flavour shoppers expect; however, meeting the sugar number alone does not guarantee consumer acceptance. For a drink targeting the 4.5g/100ml 2028 threshold, the technical challenge is to reduce enough sugar to create regulatory headroom while preserving sweetness dynamics, mouthfeel, flavour balance and repeat-use acceptance.
From 1 January 2028, the UK soft drinks levy 2028 changes will lower the SDIL sugar threshold from 5g to 4.5g per 100ml and remove the existing exemptions for milk-based and milk-substitute drinks with added sugar [1]. Current 2026 rates are 20.8p per litre for drinks containing 5g or more but less than 8g sugar per 100ml, and 27.8p per litre for drinks containing 8g or more [2]. Milkshakes, RTD coffees and qualifying sweetened plant-based drinks will therefore require renewed scope assessment; qualifying milk-based drinks are subject to an allowable lactose deduction [1]. For manufacturers, the objective should not be to formulate exactly to 4.5g. Low sugar drink reformulation should create sufficient analytical headroom while preserving the sensory profile of the current beverage. For milk-based drinks, the levy calculation generally deducts sugars derived from lactose in milk or milk products; for milk-substitute drinks, the threshold applies to total sugar content, so confirm the product category and calculation method against HMRC guidance. Levy rates are date-sensitive: verify the rate table in force on the publication date, and do not rely on the March 2026 guidance alone to substantiate a later 2026 rate statement.
Rate and source clarification: HMRC’s guidance states the rates effective from 1 April 2026 as £2.08 per 10 litres (£0.208 per litre, or 20.8p/litre) for the lower band and £2.78 per 10 litres (£0.278 per litre, or 27.8p/litre) for the higher band. These are the current rates at the time of writing; verify the live HMRC schedule again immediately before publication because rates and operative rules can change.
The 4.6–4.9g/100ml range is particularly exposed because these beverages sit just above the 2028 UK Soft Drinks Industry Levy (SDIL) threshold. IFS analysis found that approximately 8% of soft-drink litres sold in 2023 were in the 4.5–5g band, compared with 2% before the original levy; the post-SDIL average was about 10% [3]. These are historical measures reported by the IFS for the periods and categories defined in its analysis; they should not be presented as a current-year estimate or forecast.
Interpretation limit: the IFS figures describe historical market distributions under the study’s stated definitions and time periods. They are useful for prioritising portfolio review, but they do not predict the outcome for an individual SKU or establish that every product at 4.6–4.9g/100ml will incur the same commercial or sensory risk.
The technical challenge is not simply removing 0.1–0.4g of sugar. Manufacturers must determine whether an incremental reduction can preserve sensory parity, or whether sweetener-system optimisation and broader beverage matrix optimisation are required. Excessive reduction can affect sweetness, mouthfeel and flavour, while limited regulatory headroom can increase compliance risk. Establish regulatory headroom using a validated method for levy-relevant sugar concentration, account for analytical uncertainty and batch variation, and confirm the applicable calculation rules before setting the internal target.
Reformulation decision: Use incremental sugar reduction where sensory parity is maintained; move to broader sweetener or matrix optimisation when further reduction compromises consumer acceptance.
Lower-sugar products can gain substantial market share, but this does not mean every reformulated beverage will be accepted. Diet drinks reached 74% of GB take-home soft-drink litres, up from 62% pre-levy [3]. In a model drink, sweetness reductions beyond 47% were rejected by sweet likers and beyond 68% by sweet dislikes, demonstrating substantial variation in sensory tolerance [4]. These 47% and 68% values are study-specific rejection thresholds from a model-drink experiment, not universal cut-offs for all beverage categories or consumer populations; use them as evidence of segment variability rather than as direct formulation targets.
For beverage manufacturers, the key distinction is average liking versus segment-level rejection. Consumer sensory testing of drinks should therefore compare the current product with reformulated variants using overall liking, sweetness JAR, aftertaste, mouthfeel, preference and purchase intent, with predefined segment-level acceptance criteria. Before testing, define the primary outcome, sample-size rationale, segment-level analysis plan and an explicit acceptance rule, such as a pre-specified non-inferiority margin with its confidence interval; a non-significant difference alone does not establish equivalence.
Table 1. Consumer Acceptance Framework for Reformulated Drinks
Consumer response | Manufacturer assessment |
Accept | No meaningful loss in liking, preference or purchase intent The acceptance rule should be defined before testing, using a pre-specified non-inferiority margin or another justified decision criterion with uncertainty reported. |
Tolerate | Sensory change is detectable but commercially acceptable |
Reject | Off-notes, mouth-drying, thinness or sweetness imbalance reduce acceptance |
The objective is not simply the highest average liking, but the best balance of regulatory headroom, sensory performance and consumer acceptance.
Sucrose contributes beyond sweetness, influencing dissolved solids, viscosity, flavour delivery and sensory balance. A reduction of approximately 0.5g/100ml can therefore produce perceptible changes even when sweetness intensity is restored [6]. This is a formulation risk rather than a universal effect size: the magnitude and direction of change depend on the beverage matrix, starting formulation, sweetener system and processing conditions.
High-intensity sweeteners can differ from sucrose in onset, peak and persistence. Matching sweetness intensity at one time point may not reproduce the original temporal profile. [5]
Sugar reduction can expose masked bitterness, while some sweetener systems may introduce off notes. Evaluate the complete formulation, rather than attributing the effect to one ingredient.
Lower sugar reduces dissolved solids and can affect viscosity and perceived fullness. Restoring sweetness alone may leave the beverage thin or less rounded.
Reduced sweetness alters the perceived relationship between sweetness, acidity and flavour, potentially making the beverage sharper or less balanced even when pH is largely unchanged.
The formulation response should therefore target the diagnosed sensory failure, rather than simply increasing sweetener intensity.
Decision rule: set the acceptable change in overall liking and key sensory attributes before unblinding the results. Justify the non-inferiority margin using product context, measurement reliability and commercial risk; report confidence intervals and segment-level outcomes. Do not treat a statistically non-significant difference as proof that the reformulated product is equivalent to the control.
Not legal advice. In Great Britain, “low sugar” liquids need no more than 2.5g per 100ml, so a 4.4g drink avoids the levy but cannot claim it. “Reduced sugars” needs at least 30% less than a similar product and no higher energy, and same-meaning wording counts [9]. “New recipe” messaging may build trust yet prime shoppers to notice change, sharpening the taste-health paradox. SDIL liability and eligibility to make a regulated nutrition claim are separate assessments. Verify the applicable Great Britain nutrition- and health-claims rules, the comparator and all product-specific conditions before approving claim wording.
🧪 Formulator’s Note: In dairy and dairy-alternative drinks, reducing sucrose alters the matrix, not just sweetness. Recheck protein stability, sedimentation, viscosity, fat separation, emulsion stability, particle size, hydrocolloid functionality, pH, thermal processing, flavour release, shelf life and solids balance.
FRL’s formulation-led consumer testing approach is designed to expose acceptance risk pre-relaunch. Our beverage sugar reduction reformulation services start with trained descriptive analysis against the current product, then sweetener reformulation taste testing. Central location testing (CLT) adds consumer sensory testing metrics: JAR and penalty analysis, preference, purchase intent, demographic segmentation and choice-based methods. Extended home-use testing (HUT) tracks repeat use as consumer acceptance testing. CLT captures controlled, immediate sensory responses, whereas HUT evaluates repeat-use experience in consumers’ normal context. Neither method alone proves commercial success; interpret both against predefined acceptance criteria and alongside stability, claims and regulatory checks.
Figure 1. FRL’s Pre-Relaunch Consumer Test Ladder: each gate is passed against predefined criteria before the next begins. The decision criteria should explicitly cover levy-relevant sugar measurement and analytical headroom, sensory acceptance, stability, and regulatory and nutrition-claim review.
England only: location restrictions (since 1 October 2022) and volume-price promotions (from 1 October 2025) cover pre-packed drinks scoring 1+ on the Nutrient Profiling Model (NPM) [7]. UK-wide, from 5 January 2026, paid online advertising of identifiable less healthy products is banned; TV is limited to after 9 pm [8]. Assess the promotions regime and advertising restrictions separately: their geographic scope, product definitions and exemptions differ, and the applicable rules should be verified for the target market and campaign before launch.
Scope note: the promotion and advertising regimes use their own legal definitions, product-scope tests and exemptions. A drink should not be classified as restricted solely because it is marketed as low sugar or because it is subject to SDIL assessment; check the applicable Nutrient Profiling Model and the relevant rules for the product, placement, medium and jurisdiction before campaign approval.
Purpose: This work-back links sugar reduction, sensory validation, consumer acceptance, stability, claims and regulatory readiness before the 2028 threshold takes effect. A product should advance only when the pre-agreed analytical, sensory, stability and regulatory gates are met; document the evidence and unresolved risks at each gate.
Analytical release checkpoint: document the test method, its suitability for the product matrix, replicate results, measurement uncertainty and expected batch-to-batch variation. Set the internal formulation target with sufficient headroom below the applicable SDIL threshold; do not assume a result close to the threshold will remain compliant across production lots. Confirm the applicable category-specific sugar calculation with HMRC guidance before finalising the specification.
Food Research Lab supports beverage sugar reduction R&D, sweetener reformulation, sensory and consumer testing, pilot manufacturing, stability evaluation and regulatory alignment for UK market readiness.
Preparing for the 2028 UK Soft Drinks Industry Levy requires more than achieving a lower sugar value. Manufacturers need to balance regulatory headroom, sensory performance, consumer acceptance, stability and commercial readiness through structured reformulation and validation. A defensible decision should use predefined acceptance thresholds and confidence intervals, not average liking alone, and should account for the product’s target segments and intended use occasion.
Food Research Lab supports end-to-end beverage sugar reduction R&D, including formulation optimisation, sensory and consumer testing, pilot manufacturing, stability evaluation and regulatory alignment. The final scope and claims should be confirmed against current HMRC and applicable UK nutrition-claims guidance before commercial release.
The levy measures sugar concentration, not sensory acceptance. Reducing sugar further can alter sweetness linger, bitterness, mouthfeel and flavour balance, creating consumer rejection despite achieving the target sugar level. Levy classification and nutrition-claim eligibility are separate checks; verify the applicable product category, calculation rules and claim conditions independently.
There is no universal baseline. Compare the reformulated beverage against the current-product control, using predefined sensory, statistical and commercial acceptance criteria before testing. Include the current product as a control, a justified sample-size plan, pre-specified outcomes and an acceptance margin or decision threshold; report confidence intervals and segment-level findings.
Central Location Testing (CLT) measures controlled, immediate sensory responses, while Home-Use Testing (HUT) captures repeated-use experience. Differences in temporal sweetness, aftertaste and overall acceptance can therefore emerge over repeated consumption. CLT and HUT should be interpreted as complementary methods; neither replaces shelf-life, stability or regulatory verification.
Build consumer testing into staged sugar reduction beverage R&D: sweetener screening in Q1 2027, CLT in Q2, and HUT in Q3. Final drink product development should proceed only after predefined sensory, stability, claims and regulatory criteria are met. At each gate, record the analytical method and uncertainty, confirm regulatory headroom, and document the evidence supporting progression.
[1] HM Revenue & Customs. (2026, July 13). Changes to the Soft Drinks Industry Levy. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/changes-to-the-soft-drinks-industry-levy/soft-drink-industry-levy-changes
[2] HM Revenue & Customs. (2026, March 25). Check if your drink is liable for the Soft Drinks Industry Levy. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/check-if-your-drink-is-liable-for-the-soft-drinks-industry-levy
[3] Brogaard, M., & Vyas, G. (2026). Assessing recent changes to the Soft Drinks Industry Levy. Institute for Fiscal Studies. https://doi.org/10.1920/re.ifs.2026.0023
[4] Peng, M., Ginieis, R., Abeywickrema, S., McCormack, J., & Prescott, J. (2023). Rejection thresholds for sweetness reduction in a model drink predict dietary sugar intake. Food Quality and Preference, 110, Article 104965. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodqual.2023.104965
[5] Andersen, G. B. H., Christensen, C. L. D., Castura, J. C., Alexi, N., Byrne, D. V., & Kidmose, U. (2024). Sugar replacement in chocolate-flavored milk: Differences in consumer segments’ liking of sweetener systems relate to temporal perception. Beverages, 10(3), Article 54. https://doi.org/10.3390/beverages10030054
[6] Ramsey, I., Liu, J., Swiegers, J. H., & Oladokun, O. (2025). From sweetness to mouthfeel: A review on overcoming sensory barriers in sugar-free beverages. International Journal of Food Science, 2025, Article 2345722. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC12639530/
[7] Department of Health and Social Care. (2023, September 29). Restricting promotions of products high in fat, sugar or salt by location and by volume price. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/restricting-promotions-of-products-high-in-fat-sugar-or-salt-by-location-and-by-volume-price
[8] Department of Health and Social Care. (2025, June 4). Restricting advertising of less healthy food or drink on TV and online: Products in scope. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/restricting-advertising-of-less-healthy-food-or-drink-on-tv-and-online-products-in-scope/restricting-advertising-of-less-healthy-food-or-drink-on-tv-and-online-products-in-scope
[9] European Parliament and Council. (2006). Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 December 2006 on nutrition and health claims made on foods, Annex (UK version). legislation.gov.uk. https://legislation.gov.uk/eur/2006/1924/annexes/2006-12-20
Get a free packaging compliance review within 24 hours.
Food Research Lab strives for excellence in new Food, Beverage and Nutraceutical Product Research and Development by offering cutting edge scientific analysis and expertise.